Showing posts with label Fyodor Dostoyevsky. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fyodor Dostoyevsky. Show all posts

Saturday, May 12, 2018

272. Still trying to become a better person


Before I resume A History of Europe...


Why I "green"

Of the many reasons I "green," the most difficult for me is the one I learned (again) this past weekend. The main reasons are that it's "good" work, in the Buddhist sense, and it both gets me out of the house to events I would otherwise never see, and it keeps me in good physical shape. These are the reasons that easily come to mind. But the other reason is just as important, if more difficult for me to remember.

I have a list of things I need to have with me when I leave the house for a greening gig. At the top of that list I've written in the largest letters, "CHILL." What I have in mind here are the annoying recycling scavengers and the annoying food vendors, two groups that make our work harder than it has to be. But there's yet another group that I need to chill about, and here's an example from this past weekend at Cinco de Mayo.

This one, dip-shit, event attendee decided the place to eat his lunch was sitting right next to one of our eco-stations with the pizza box holding his food actually resting across two of the eco-station box containers (landfill and compost). Not only was his pizza box blocking me from cleaning out the station, but the chair he was sitting on all but blocked me from approaching the eco-station. To get past him, I had to lift the almost full compost bag I was carrying over him and his pizza. He took exception to this. And he was right, I was being an ass-hole. 

This is a prime example of a situation where I should just chill. It isn't that important and, as satisfying as it was, my actions were unprofessional. Fuck-wittery will always exist and reacting to it doesn't help. I can blame the fact I was running late for my lunch break, but regardless, this is something I need to work on. 

Otherwise, the event went smoothly. My favorite crew chief was working the event so, at the end, I felt fine taking over my end of the street and directing the others in closing down our stations. With anyone else I would have needed to clear it with them, but J___ and I are always on the same page with things like this. I had the busier half of the event, yet we wrapped up first and then helped the others shut down the other half. And thus more recycling and compost was diverted.

Tomorrow, back to Pirenne... I'm almost sure.


P.S.

I'm still procrastinating, not sure why. Anyway, last night I had another dream that featured one of my parents -- not my mother, which would have been appropriate since tomorrow is Mother's Day. There's certainly nothing surprising about frequently dreaming about your parents, but what is a little uncanny is when you wake up, or semi-wake up, and remember -- have to reestablish in your mind -- that they are actually dead. I'm sure this is devastating for parents who have lost their children. 

There is a period of time, in these situations, when your mental assertions do not seem particularly convincing, given the evidence of the dream you are still coming out of. You think, could I be wrong about this? Which is the dream? 

I remain grateful that in my dreams my parents are always the people they were, not what they had been reduced to at the time they died. Dostoevsky, in The Brothers K, insists that people become most themselves as they approach death. I have yet to witness this. But even if that actually happened, would you want to remember people in your dreams the way you had known them all your life, or the way they had been for a brief time just before death? 


And here are some random photographs. First the Salesforce Tower. Not sure if they are entirely finished inside, but this is the way the exterior is going to look,


Then something I've noticed in the past but never had my camera with me to capture. See if you can figure out what this is,



Below should be easier to make out,


And below here it should be even more obvious,



Someone really did a good job removing every last bit of paper from the fliers and other items stapled to this post.


Sunday, June 25, 2017

164. The Road to Character


Previous - 162. It's been a while


Sports!

Back by no demand.

As usual, I'm writing not as the normal fan but in response to something remarkable. Our local basketball team, the Warriors, are in the Finals for the third straight year against the same other team -- the Cleveland Cavaliers. They won in 2015. They suffered a painful loss in 2016. Now they're doing "best 2 out of 3." 

After the loss in the seventh game last year, the team when out and acquired one of the best players in basketball to fill the "three" position where they had been weakest. (Confusingly, the three position is also known as "small forward" but Kevin Durant, the new three is one of the taller players on the court.) KD, as he is commonly referred to, got an amazing amount of criticism for leaving his previous team, the competitive Oklahoma City Thunder, where he had been one of the two core stars. At GSW (Golden State Warriors), he is one of the four core stars -- if you can describe all but one of the starters as a "core." This is now an All-Star team at virtually every position except the five (center.) But the five is where it gets interesting for me. But let's stick with KD for a moment.

The notion that an athlete should make employment decisions based on preserving competitiveness in the league is odd. I can't imagine anyone actually doing that. The league might come up with rules that have that effect, but the player is always going to do what seems to be in his own best interest. In this case, KD seems to have believed that joining GSW would give him the best chance of getting a ring (winning a Championship) while also making him a better player by helping him improve on defense -- a strength of GSW. 

And, listening to the analysis of the first two games which GSW have won decisively, what you most hear is what a revelation KD's play on defense has been. Nearly everyone says something like, "We all knew he was one of the best scorers in basketball but the way he is dominating as a defender is something new." And when the commentators are players -- either retired or stars who's teams have already been eliminated -- they are clear that the reason for KD's excellence is that on his new team he isn't expected to do everything himself. Surrounded by players who also excel at defense, he can do more with less. 

His decision to join GSW is looking more and more like the no-brainer I always thought it was. Any player with his talent would have been a fool not to have made the decision to join what is generally accepted to be the best run team in the league.

And that brings us to the five position. To sign KD GSW had to part ways with all the players who had previously played center for them and to acquire new players at mostly bargain basement salaries. David West was an experienced older player who cared more about a shot at a ring than money. JaVale McGee had become a joke for his absentminded play and GSW signed him on an almost "what the hell, we'll give him a look" whim. Both of these players, along with the wonderfully named Zaza Pachulia, have managed to find ways to contribute to GSW's success and JaVale has even become a fan favorite for his enthusiastic play. While GSW is now much stronger at the three because of KD, it seems to be largely overlooked how much stronger they are at the five with these new members of the team.

And there are some younger players who've found ways to contribute. The world may see the Warriors as four All-Stars, but the role players -- older or new to the league -- are an important part of the picture. When GSW is dominating a game at the end of the third quarter, they can put in their reserves who almost always can hold their own, giving the starters time to rest for much of the final quarter. 

The other thing about this team is that they have a lot of fun, which is fun to watch. 

Thanks to my delay in publishing this, GSW has now gone to win the championship four games vs one loss. KD was the unanimous selection for Most Valuable Player in the series. 



The Road to Character by David Brooks

Random House 2015

Chapter four is about Dorothy Day who is explained in terms of the "Dostoyevskan" vs the "Tolstoyan". This must require a familiarity with these authors that goes beyond The Brothers Karamazov and Anna Karenina -- the only novels I've read recently -- because this makes no sense to me. 

While there is something of Levin to Day -- her determined seeking after some greater truth and more supportive life -- I would just stick with a comparison with the Karamazov boys. She seems to be a curious mix of Dmitri and Alyosha. But mostly Dmitri. She is what Dmitri dreams of becoming while locked up at the end of the novel. And just as he doubts his ability to really change his life, Day never really seems to find the peace she keeps seeking. Ivan would tear her to pieces... and this despite her being familiar with his Grand Inquisitor.

What she actually reminds me of, even more than a Karamazov, is a heroin addict. She is always in need of support even as that support grows less effective. Even if she switched to methadone, and became a determined methadonian, she would need occasionally to add some real heroin to the mix. 

What I can't see is her putting herself in the hands of an Elder. Her's seems to have been a very self-willed life of "obedience, servitude, and self-surrender" and sacrifice. I'm self-willed, too, but I'm not trying to turn my life over to God. 


Yesterday I worked the Sikh Parade and Festival here. Aside from the distinctive dress, it was similar to many other events we work, with lots of food generating lots of (mostly compost) waste. By chance, it was a cold and windy day and, after we had secured our eco-station trash boxes to trees to prevent them blowing away, we were informed that wasn't allowed. So rather than doing my usual roving sorting of a bunch of busy stations, I was stuck at one station (that looked to be the busiest) as I was both monitoring the station and preventing it from blowing away. We had to have a person at each un-secured station -- which meant there weren't enough people to do roving sorting in other areas, and those stations (the ones I had put up, as it happens) got completely trashed.

But why this is going here is that unlike Dorothy Day, I realized while standing at my station for most of the day, correcting the sorting mistakes of the crowd, I do what I do because of the WORK not because of the people. 

I would say she was motivated by her own need to help others, rather than their need. This works well for both parties as the people being "helped" often have no interest in changing, which means the "helpers" will never run out of people to enable, I mean "help."

But let's say I'm wrong about that. Maybe God really loves these people whose lives he has fucked up and God, the helper, and the helpee (?) all benefit from these good works. My motivation is quite different. There are two different ways of looking (justifying) what I do, but neither of them has anything to do with people exactly.

My goal when I work an event is to divert as much waste from the landfill as possible. (Also, to keep the event working smoothly, which means no over-flowing trash containers.) If I ever thought you could educate people (and especially vendors) to do their own sorting, it was a long time ago. I will explain as much as I can to the public (and the vendors) because it's part of my job, and I think I'm pretty good at it. But I don't expect them to give a shit. I'm more interested in getting the compost and recycling out than in transforming the crowd into environmentalists. My job satisfaction comes from looking at well sorted dumpsters at the end of the day. That's the first aspect of "the work."

Unfortunately, just as in my coding and technical writing career, I don't have complete control over the fate of my work. I've heard about the composting facilities where our dumpsters of food and paper get sent to, but I've never visited one and don't know how good of a job they really do. I don't even know for sure that all our dumpsters get sent there. And at some events I bag but don't dump the bags into the dumpsters, so, despite my bag labeling, all I can say is that I've done a super job of collecting a well sorted bag (usually of compost.) 

Just as some of my best coding and best writing was for projects I either didn't care about or that were aborted before completion, I'm still satisfied with my work when the actual diversion rate falls short of what I would have hoped for, due to circumstances. 

Of course, Dorothy Day and Mother Teresa may have felt the same way about their work.


Apotheosis
p102 Finally reading the end of the section of Dorothy Day and we're explicitly into how she, in the 1960s, was opposed both to the "bourgeois culture of commerce" and the "bohemian culture... [of] self-gratification." 

p103 Day's life... was about the surrender of self and ultimately the transcendence of self... Through The Long Loneliness and her other writings she practiced a sort of public confession... Day's confessions were theological, too. Her attempts to understand herself and humanity were really efforts to understand God.
...

p104 [Shortly before she died to Robert Coles] ...I was going to try to make a summary [of her life] for myself, write what mattered most -- but I couldn't do it. I just sat there and thought of our Lord, His visit to us all those centuries ago, and I said to myself that my great luck was to have had Him on my mind for so long in my life!


Coles wrote, "I heard the catch in her voice as she spoke, and soon her eyes were a little most, but she quickly started talking of her great love for Tolstoy..."


I need to add something here from earlier in the chapter,

p79 She protested on behalf of the working classes. But the most vital dramas of her life were going on inside. She had become an even more avid reader, especially of Tolstoy and Dostoyevsky (sic). 

It's hard now to recapture how seriously people took novel reading then, or at least how seriously Day and others took it -- reading important works as wisdom literature, believing that supreme artists possessed insights that could be handed down as revelation, trying to mold one's life around the heroic and deep souls one found in books. Day read as if her whole life depended upon it.


...Day was "moved to the depths of my being" by Dostoyevsky...
 

Maybe I should re-title my blog, "Wisdom Literature." Maybe the author chose to focus on the Russians (this chapter really does assume a good deal from the reader), but I'm surprised she wasn't also influenced by The Magic Mountain, though that may have been too dry and cerebral. It's Father Zossima, not Ivan or Alyosha that attracted her in The Brothers Karamazov. A quick search on "Dorothy Day" and "The Magic Mountain" doesn't reveal much.

Do Millennials (or Gen Y or even Gen X) read novels the same way we did? Since "we" was a tiny fraction of my (and previous) generations, I suspect there are still some people who do. I think fiction is a perfectly reasonable way to do philosophy and a better than average way to expose others to philosophy. And it even is educational in two directions, the author has to consider what will attract an audience. I'm surprised The Magic Mountain was as influential as it was, but it's obvious why people read Tolstoy and Dostoevsky, and metaphysics was the least of it. 

Neighborhood characters

There's this small, older but not elderly, woman who is almost always walking, standing, or sitting somewhere on the three blocks of the street just below my building. She's probably a couple inches shorter than she started out, and I have a morbid curiosity to see what an X-ray of her spine would look like. The reason I notice her is that she is always smoking. I'm also curious as to whether she is on the street to smoke or if smoking just gives her something to do as she roams these blocks. I'm pretty sure she lives in a building in about the middle of her range, but that's just because I most frequently see her there.

If I were the police -- and if I really cared about neighborhood policing -- I would be on good terms with her since she probably sees everything that happens on that section of street.


The second character I see much less frequently, only when I go to my second favorite pizzeria (this is not based on the quality of the pizza, neither my first nor second pizzerias have particularly good pizza). She seems to spend most of her time in this restaurant which she treats as her home. She opens and closes windows to suit herself. She makes them change what's on the TV to suit herself. She seems "personable" and knows everyone's name, but she drives me nuts and if I worked there I would poison her.

And she's both loud and chatty, which is why I've left the pizzeria and am finishing this at Starbuck's.


Next - 165. George Eliot, revisited

Saturday, June 24, 2017

163. It's been a while


Previous - 162. Becoming Wise

Link to Table of Contents



Sorry to leave you hanging if you were at all interested in Becoming Wise. This pause was not planned.

Becoming Wise

p162 Western Christianity lost some of the cleansing power of mystery when it became a bedfellow with empire and later, again, in its headlock with science. I sensed a discomfort in my grandfather at his own large and active mind, a nervous reluctance to acknowledge things the Bible did not or could not explain. For they might be delivered over to science's godless certainties, and then they were lost to the faithful forever...

p163 As this century opened, physicists, cosmologists, and astronomers were no longer pushing mystery out, but welcoming it back in...

p226  Shane Claybourne claims that "spittin' image" is shorthand for "the spirit and image." I like that. But does it really work if no one remembers that's what it means?


What I'm getting in all this is that Tippett -- even more perhaps than Lamott -- sees faith as a tribal human characteristic. It's something that binds groups together, often in opposition with other groups. The Amish and Ultra Orthodox Jews and Wahabi Arab women are like the tribal peoples who wear neck-rings or lip-plates. The fashions they use to distinguish themselves from others are arbitrary -- as are all fashions. What is important is that they adhere to the tribal fashion.

The tricky part when it comes to religion is, how to you sell the fashion to the young of the tribe without making judgements against outsiders? Can you say, "This is completely meaningless and stupid but it's this thing we do"?

And beyond that, can you say, Our religion and our God is this wonderful thing we've made up and we're better for believing it, but, you know, don't try to peek behind the curtains?


And she never does even touch on the problem of evil. To be fair, the kind of faith described in the previous paragraph doesn't require confronting that problem. Religion is simply one of the ways we deal with the evil we run into. If your God is pretend you can sidestep so many tiresome meta-ethical problems. 

She does talk very briefly about people who were recent victims of evil, secular martyrs. (Secular in that they didn't suffer and die for their faith, exactly.) Still, I don't think -- in a book like this -- you can just pass over evil without comment. 

Dostoevsky was not arguing for a pretend God, so he, through Ivan Karamazov, spent a great deal of time talking about evil. But did he come up with a neat explanation or justification? Didn't he just leave it at mystery? Both Dostoevsky and Tippett I think hope the problem will go away when people get in touch with their inner vulnerability. To which Michel Foucault says, "Ha!" Or to stick to The Brothers Karamazov, Pavel, de Sade's stand-in (or the straw-man representing de Sade), says, "Ha!" 


Martha Grimes mysteries

Here's something I can't explain, when I put back the books on my "featured fiction" shelf, there wasn't room for them all. I had to pick a title to remove and noticed a Richard Jury mystery, The Lamorna Wink that I didn't remember. I'm reading it now and I really don't think I've read it before. I'm around a third into it and so far Jury has not really been in it, it's all about Melrose Plant. 

In every Jury mystery Grimes has to visit her characters in Northants and in London, and we just wrapped our short visit to London where everyone, including Cyril the cat, are mostly just waiting for Jury to reappear. 

I'm not complaining, I was wondering when we would see Cyril, and it was nice to finally get some crucial backstory on Melrose. There's a murder and a disappeared person and we still haven't a clue what Jury is doing in Ireland. All that is fine, I'm reading slowly and just enjoying going where Grimes wants to take me. 
 

Photo update

Time passes. Here's how Salesforce Tower has progressed,



Before.


Now.

And here's how the work on the Van Ness BRT is coming along. The median is entirely removed and paved over except where the few trees are being preserved. It looks pretty silly,



Before.


Now.

The Road to Character by David Brooks

I'm still not sure how best to deal with this book. This is why I have not been posting for a while now. I want to build up a backlog so I can post regularly once I start up again, but wasn't sure how much detail I wanted to get into. 

This book is building up and cross-pollinating in a way that I'm not even sure is conscious to the author. Either he is being very stealthy about bringing up some interesting theological concepts, or he is accidentally bumping into things that I see connections between but he doesn't. The smart thing would be to wait until I've read it all and then go back and blog as I make a second pass through the material... so that's off the table.

I'm going to go ahead and post what I have as I complete my first pass with the understanding that I will be coming back to some of this later. My other problem is that Christian minutia relating to Augustine and Jansen (that I have so little interest in parsing) seems to be as central to this as are the more interesting (to me) religious ideas of Dostoevsky and Tolstoy. And if I can paraphrase Clausewitz, this book could be viewed as The Magic Mountain's "regieren" by other means. And with Brooks arguing Naphtha's position. 

Again, I can't tell how conscious the author is of all this. I'm pretty sure Dostoevsky would be appalled by some of the people presented as exemplars. Though this would be less true of Naphtha. (I'm almost at the end now and am even more puzzled by Brooks's actual position. Either he's oblivious or using misdirection to prevent us from seeing what he's actually arguing for.)

In any event, I can promise you a return of the Port Royal gang, or at least some of their core ideas, yet another questioning of the secular, bourgeois world order, another pass at George Eliot, and some great stuff about Montaigne -- who keeps popping up, or rather who has occasionally shouted something or other from off-stage, but now can finally take a bow.



Next - 164. The Road to Character

Monday, May 1, 2017

154. The Sutra...


Previous - 153. Violation


Still Violating

"On Being Text"

When you pick up a collection of essays you can't really expect anything in particular, but I have to say that this is not what I was expecting from Tisdale -- not that I'm complaining at all. This essay begins talking about the academic penchant for bundling writer's together into anthologies for educational purposes. Tisdale starts by seeing it as a not unappreciated new source of income, but then goes on (after noticing that one editor has botched her biography) to actually read the collections. She also reprises her ad hoc education -- dropping out of high school and weaving through several universities, where she took no "literature" classes -- before finally getting a degree.

p234 ...the moment the students finish reading, they must start to dissect. I'm afraid that what the students of these books are really learning is what college students learn about so many subjects: how to take things apart, but not how to put them together.
...

p236 ...Literary analysis begins by presuming that writing can be understood by understanding its parts. The process is, in fact, called dissection, a term usually applied to dead things.
...

...Reading my own critics has taught me a little bit about my work and rather a lot about certain critics.
...

p240 How would I change college literature classes?... Read, read, read, and then try to explain how it feels. Read a book because someone you like tells you it's a good book. Listen to other readers when they react. Read some more. I believe that one reason I learned to write is that no one ever really tried to teach me, or... no one ever tried to tell me what a writer was supposed to be like...

p241 [From her note at the end of the essay] ...Anthologies give us a window into everything wrong with how we teach writing -- and reading -- and how one is actually read. It's not pretty.

I did take literature and history and philosophy classes, but I still agree with her. A good university philosophy department is the place to go to have your interest in philosophy deflated. And Thomas Mann, another autodidact, would agree with her as well. Academia (you would think) would be a magical place where people really cared about these topics, that few people in general care about, but instead it is where interest goes to die.

There's a great deal more here that I could have quoted, it's interesting to see an author respond to what is said about her writing by "professional" critics. What does please me is who Tisdale finds herself grouped with in these anthologies, Thurber and White and the other writers she mentions here. That would be nice.


"Twitchy"

What a great essay title. I'm not sure I'm entirely happy with Tisdale's categorization as a memorist... even though I think she's the one who suggested it. Her subject is life and she starts with herself, as we all do. Since we keep coming back to subjectivity, how nothing can really be known objectively, what isn't memoir to some extent? 

This essay is about, or at least starts with, a trip to the dentist to have her spectacularly bad teeth worked on. This requires a great deal of nitrous oxide which seems to be Tisdale's drug of choice. 

My teeth are as good as Tisdale's are bad, and yet a moment of wild abandon with a nutty biscotti at a delightful garden party last Sunday left me without the sole -- massive -- filling in my mouth. In fear the tooth would collapse if I forgot and put pressure on it, I rushed to the dentist the next day and had it refilled. Over $400 for those of you keeping score at home.

So I just this week spent time in a dentist's chair-of-discomfort. I wasn't offered nitrous. My iPod is on it's last legs so that's not an option. So I just had to lie back and be thankful this only happens about once a decade.

I was given nitrous once when three wisdom teeth were to be extracted without any other general anesthesia. I don't recall it doing anything. (And I don't recommend having your wisdom teeth pulled like that.) But what Tisdale's nitrous experience does remind me of is the intravenous anesthesia I got when they extracted the rogue wisdom tooth that somehow traveled sideways into the next tooth, leaving the cavity my massive filling is a reminder of. I was conscious but unconcerned with what was happening in my mouth. My thought processes didn't seem (to me) to be affected -- compared, for example, to drinking a bottle of wine -- and there was no hang-over or aftereffect when the procedure was over. I was told I was going to get a Valium IV, and I think I took a Valium before, but at the last minute there was a change of plan which I never quite understood, so I don't really know what they gave me, except that it wasn't what my friends had gotten that knocked them out, left them groggy, and finally resulted in vomiting later on. 

Tisdale goes on to explain her phobia in terms of scary childhood dental work from her (step)grandfather. But what she is averse to is what I dislike as well, the smell and sounds, the surprising pressures, and, for me, the discomfort of simply holding my jaw wide open for so long (that was the worst part of the three wisdom tooth extraction.) If I had access to Valium, and knew I was getting my work done ahead of time, I would have dosed myself up the same way Tisdale uses nitrous. By the time I need to get this filling replaced, I will have forgotten all this again.

She describes an annoying friend who goes to the dentist eager to learn if his flossing has paid off. I'm so much worse than this. Not only do I floss but I use these special little brushes between my teeth. My goal in life is to have the hygienist say, "There's nothing here for me to do" and run off sobbing. And I'm getting closer and closer each year. And yet I react to hearing the words "root canal" about the same way she does. 


"The Sutra of Maggots and Blowflies"

Finally! This was my introduction to Sallie Tisdale and it is so unlike everything else I've read by her. For one thing it's as much about Buddhism as it is about flies. It's the only place where she really gets philosophical. And it's like a concise version of Annie Dillard's A Pilgrim at Tinker Creek when it comes to the amorality of nature.

What I noticed this reading is something that Dostoevsky would have loved. Near the end she writes at length about the role flies and their progeny play in decomposing bodies. Then, talking about the Buddha, she writes this, 

p311 ...What lucky flies smelled the flowery scent of the Buddha's death, and came -- flowing through the air like a river in the sky, a river of flies? What lucky maggots were born in his body, in the moist heat of the afternoon while the disciples still mourned? The maggots and blowflies are the words of the old Buddhas, singing of the vast texture of things, a lullaby of birth and death. They came and turned him into juice and soil, the Buddha flowing gloriously like cream into the ground.

I'm thinking about the shocking (to the monks) decomposition of Father Zossima shortly after his death. Of course, I'm not sure this works with what Dostoevsky intended this to mean. But it would seem that Zossima would have enjoyed the interpretation. 
 

Ugly

Yesterday I was looking at some photos taken looking down from the top of Salesforce Tower. This got me thinking about when architects decided that the tops and bottoms of skyscrapers didn't matter? (Or, if we think of the architects as thinking like toddlers, that we can't see the tops, at least.) 

In one shot, there was a great view of the Shell Building and several other handsome structures from the École des Beaux-Arts period of architect education. These structures still appear as perfect sculptural constructions, as neatly designed at the top as where they meet the sidewalk. By contrast, many of the glass, curtain-wall monoliths from the 1960 and 1970s (and beyond) have unsightly mechanical tumors on their flat roofs while their bases seem completely arbitrary. If it weren't for the larger height of the street level floors, you would think that the entire tower was simply extruded out of the ground like a plant shoot with an undifferentiated stem. The few postmodernist structures here do a bit better at the top, but recently they seem to have gone back to pretending no one can see up there. I'll give César Pelli credit for giving Salesforce Tower a better top, but then it's intended to be a focus and focal point for the whole city.




The Shell Building is the petite tower in the left foreground between two flat-topped towers. There are more, old buildings from the early 20th century above and to the left between Shell and the dark mass of the BofA Tower. The other standout tower is the Russ Building. Sadly, the building that houses my gym is just out of the frame to the left of the Russ. The round tower middle right, is Phillip Johnson's 101 California. The dark, part flatiron, part round little tower just this side of 101 California has residential on top, but I don't know it's name. The former First Interstate Bank building is dead center, partly in front of the TransAmerica. The First Interstate building includes a hotel on top and was built in the middle of the block with connection to the streets on three sides, but with the other, older, buildings in that block left in place. It's my favorite large scale development in the city because it integrated itself so subtlety into the neighborhood.

Mies van der Rohe's Seagram Building does have a blunt and unsightly top but no tumors sticking up above. The way it meets the ground is a classic example of being too playful with steel and the weightless effect it can give. Like Wright and the Guggenheim, it would appear that van der Rohe also had no sense for urban life.

About the same can be said for SOM's Lever House, especially at the top. The base is better if only because it fills it's site. It's still more a celebration of steel and glass then it is something that belongs in a city.

It would seem that architects started with those examples and then simplified and made the buildings cheaper. Even the BofA tower here, which I think is an unusually handsome tall building, has protruding mechanicals rising from the top and a Seagramesque retreat from the street. I suspect one of the reasons the TransAmerica Pyramid has become so famous is that it is almost Postmodern in the way it avoids both the top and base problems, at least visually. The base is still a sterile zone in an otherwise vibrant neighborhood. I give it a pass as an instance of architectural sculpture, rather like the Burj Khalifa.




Painting a wall


I've been thinking about re-painting a wall in my living room for about six months and it's finally warm enough to have my windows open for a couple days. This evening I moved everything out of the way -- not a simple task in such a small apartment. It went about 90% the way I anticipated, which is surprisingly good. I had forgotten that I had velcroed my mirror to the wall, which makes that part of the job much easier than I was anticipating. On the other hand, I underestimated how much space my over-a-hundred-year-old desk and bookcase would take when I pulled it out. So I didn't move it as far as I planned. (I had already moved a chair out of the way to make room for the desk, and moving it back is impossible, so the chair clogs up my kitchen unnecessarily. Still, all in all it went well.

Tomorrow I will prep and prime. Tuesday I will paint and then move everything back. I've already added on a side project of putting something lighter in color at the back of the old shelves which I use as a display space. That should make my featured artifacts more visible. Maybe. We'll see.

Next - 155. Last of Tisdale

Thursday, April 13, 2017

150. Original sin


Previous - 149. Candide, God, and evil


Vertigo - the last of Dr. K

As much as I'm enjoying the commentary on Candide, I feel myself more in need of commentary for Vertigo. At the end of a passage about Kafka spending some time at a sanatorium in Riva, we get this tale of "Gracchus the huntsman" arriving in a "barque with masts of an inconceivable height and sails dark and hanging in folds" after an endless voyage. While this -- whatever it is -- is associated with Kafka, the reader who knows the next part of the book will recognize in this passage another huntsman, here we have, "...in the Black Forest, where he was on guard against the wolves which still prowled the hills at that time, he went in pursuit of a chamois -- and is this not one of the strangest items of misinformation in all the tales that have ever been told? -- he went in pursuit of a chamois and fell to his death from the face of a mountain..."

And in the next section is the other story about,

...Hans Schlag the huntsman of whom it was said that he hailed from other parts... that he had managed extensive hunting grounds in the Black Forest... 
...

...Schlag the hunter had been found dead a good hour's walk beyond his hunting ground, on the Tyrolean side of the border, at the bottom of a ravine...


And the narrator, as a child, has the body of this huntsman delivered to him on a sledge instead of a barque. And since we had just had our only sex scene in this book, between Schlag and a blonde barmaid, I suppose that makes her the "chamois."

What this means, I have no idea.
 

Candide 

"Voltaire's Escape from Pascal" by Ernst Cassirer

p167 {"Pascal tormented Voltaire, as Montaigne had tormented Pascal." The epigram is by Raymond Naves (Voltaire l'homme et l'oevre: Paris, 1942...)...

To a remarkable degree... [Montaigne, Pascal, and Voltaire] were preoccupied with a single problem, that is the relation between faith and reason, which is in effect the question of original sin. This had been the crucial controversy between Erasmus and Luther; it would be the theme of conflicts between Calvinists and Arminians on the Protestant side, between Jansenists and Jesuits within the Catholic party. Its importance is obvious. For if man's reason, no less than his will, is fatally corrupted from birth, his only hope of understanding himself or the world lies in supernatural faith. In opposition to this crucial point, all the Enlightenment philosophers united; and Voltaire, perhaps in part because the brother whom he hated was a Jansenist, powerfully impregnated with the doctrine of original sin, focused his criticism of the doctrine on its foremost Jansenist exponent, Blaise Pascal...}


The section that follows, written by Cassirer, is interesting enough, but I don't have the patience to work through the minutia of Christian theology. It's all interpretation of the shadows on cave walls to me. But Dostoevsky would be all over this.

I'm thinking the reason I ignored Dostoevsky for so long is that, while The Brothers Karamazov does a wonderful job of expressing the reality of existentialism, he himself stands outside existentialism in the philosophical tradition delineated above. I don't know (or care) what he thought of the Jansenists, but he would have opted for any of these traditions over Nietzsche. 

That said, "original sin" can be restated as our separation from nature (see also Prometheus) and this is a subject I am interested in. The problem is that it is very hard to tackle this topic from within the web of Christianity. There is always too much of the a priori (as was mentioned in the previous post, I think) which stands in the way. It's like trying to come up with a Christmas season budget with someone who still believes in Santa Claus.


My day 

I'm having a good day. An old friend's son is answering some arcane (inane?) questions about Quantum mechanics (spin, for example) and I'm dodging phone calls from Realtors about the unit for sale in our building. It seems that the Venn diagram for Realtors and People Who Prefer to Chat on the Phone Instead of Writing Emails would be a simple circle. But thanks to call screening, I can bend them to my will.

Here are the advantages of communicating by email (texting is similar):

Because it's asynchronous, both parties do not have to be free at the same time.

There is a paper trail you can refer back to when anyone gets confused about what was said.

You can easily dispatch the same information (answers to questions) to other interested parties.

It takes less time, as you don't get bogged down in pleasantries.


On the other hand, (Re: My Day) I discovered the doctor I'd been seeing before I was covered by San Francisco's single-payer health plan, doesn't accept Medicare insurance. But this is mitigated by the fact that he is also retiring this summer. This wasn't a complete surprise -- I'm also worried about losing our electrician and even the painter we liked so much, before we need them again. I suppose it would be considered discrimination if you specified you wanted to be seen by younger health care professionals so you don't outlive their careers.



Next - 151. CBF and Sisters

Monday, February 13, 2017

118. Evola & the Alt-right


Previous - 117. The Dashwoods


Social Contract

I keep coming back in my mind to America's Social Contract. Regardless of where John Locke and the guys may have wanted to start, the American Social Contract started with protecting the right of Europeans to view Native Americans and Africans as being less than human. As not having legal standing except as chattel.

The next American "revolution" was when abolitionists attacked this notion with regard to Africans which lead to the Civil War and the end of "slavery" as an institution. But when it comes down to it, it seems like Americans are not that interested in other "people's" interests when their own economic interest is involved. Many of the "Sagebrush Rebellion" issues have to do with continued exploitation of Native lands. 

The problem, in a world of robot manufacturing and the land being stressed by human population growth, is how are non-tech savvy Americans to be made whole? And this is far more than just an American problem. Because someone will find something for these people to do, just as Mussolini and Hitler did.


Perhaps, just as we need a multitude of gods and religions to suit our individual or group needs, there is no one political system that suits all people. It sounds like you're joking when you point out that the weakness of Italian Fascism was the need to pit Italian nationalism against some external force, but this does seem to be an essential requirement for all forms of extreme nationalism, and I'm sure America First-ism will tend in the same direction. I'm not even in a position to say that this isn't a necessary feature. This comes down to cultural anthropology and sociology. It may well be that the EU has pushed peace in Europe, for example, about as far as it can go. Perhaps radical pruning isn't an accident, but a necessity for European success. It certainly looks like something periodically pushes Europeans toward war.


Continued...

I've been holding onto this for days because I'm still dwelling in The House of Phlegm... (now with minimal hearing in my left ear due to congestion. Dr. Time seems to finally be getting the better of this vile plague. Maybe.)

But now I need to make this already too long post even longer as I just ran into not one, but two intriguing pieces from Medium. I will include the links below. 

I guess I'm going to start with this piece on "The Alt-right Is a Doomsday Cult." It's almost like the author has been reading my blogs. There are references to Nietzsche and to Mussolini -- and I now I have to do some research on Julius Evola. There's even a new (to me) use of "kali" to describe the period of time when Kali dances. (How have I missed Evola? His connection with Hermetic philosophy links straight back to the original Faust writings.) 

Here's a striking quote from Wiki: 

"The Jews were stigmatized, not as representatives of a biological race, but as the carriers of a world view, a way of being and thinking—simply put, a spirit—that corresponded to the ‘worst’ and ‘most decadent’ features of modernity: democracy, egalitarianism and materialism."[20]

And:

Paul Furlong wrote that "The complete Evola held views that it is fair, if somewhat summary, to categorise as elitist, racist, anti-semitic, misogynist, anti-democratic, authoritarian, and deeply anti-liberal."[7]

And finally, the real shocker:
Evola died unmarried, without children, on 11 June 1974 in Rome.

I did a quick search and found this link where the internet, in it's occult wisdom, reveals that 63% of respondents think Evola was gay. That's what I was thinking as well. And not just because he was a Barone.

Now to our second piece on the suppression of science in Franco's Spain. Now here we see exactly what I thought we should see in fascism in general, if its enemy was truly the bourgeoisie (Evola is quite clear on this in his theory of "castes.") Some quotes,

The new council ["the central agency responsible for advancing Spanish science research and exchanges with foreign scientists"] was meant to bring back a view of science that would make it compatible with conservative Catholic values, mandating it to “restore the classical and Christian unity of the sciences that was destroyed in the 18th Century.” In other words, he wanted to turn back the clock to pre-Enlightenment times...

“The Franco regime defended the literalism of the Bible, which was considered an infallible account, inspired by the word of God,” said Manuel Castillo Martos, a professor at the University of Seville and co-author of Education, Science and Ideology in Spain (1890–1950). “Scientific ideas that contradicted it, such as Darwinist evolution, were considered unacceptable.”

Now we have Naphta's doctrine made law. Given that The Magic Mountain was published in 1926 and Franco came to power 1936-1939, and that we know (from Primo Levi) that "everyone" was reading the book after it was published, one has to wonder just how influential it really was. 

The Nazis were not in a position, during the late 1930s and 1940s, to be purists when it came to bourgeois science, since they had a war to lose. But was there a long term plan to adapt something similar to (though less Catholic than) the Spanish approach to science? How would I.G. Farben have felt about that? Again, I'm not quite interested enough in this to actually read National Socialist texts. There should be a way to leave idea seeds on Medium in hopes that someone else will do your work for you.



No power to the slaves

I included a Franco quote above and then removed it because it didn't relate to what I was addressing just then, but I want to come back to it now.

“We do not believe in government through the voting booth,” he said. “The Spanish national will was never freely expressed through the ballot box. Spain has no foolish dreams.”

And this goes nicely with Evola's thoughts on caste,

In Revolt Against the Modern World, Evola developed a "general objective law: the law of the regression of the castes", claiming that "[t]he meaning of history from the most ancient times is this: the gradual decline of power and type of civilization from one to another of the four castes - sacred leaders, warrior nobility, bourgeoisie (economy, "merchants") and slaves - which in the traditional civilizations corresponded to the qualitative differentiation in the principal human possibilities."[13]

I don't think Fyodor Dostoevsky would have much of a problem with this. And neither would Naphta, of course. Though I imagine there would be some debate about who decides what between the "sacred leaders" and the "warrior nobility." And isn't it interesting that he chose the word "slaves" for the lowest caste (I'm assuming this is a decent translation.) I imagine Ford Madox Ford was familiar with Evola, I do wonder what he thought of these, Tory-er than thou views.

I do notice a couple problems for the Alt-right in installing these ideas in the New World. As Dostoevsky was aware, the U.S.A. is a pure bourgeois state. Getting rich regardless of the cost has always been the true American Dream and when Trump speaks of Making America Great Again, I'm sure that's what his followers are hearing. How do you introduce finer thoughts regarding the sacred and the noble in a land of the bourgeoisie?

And then there's religion. For Spain and Italy going to their sacred place was simply adhering to the Catholic Church -- just as it was Orthodox Christianity for Dostoevsky. But what is the sacred standard for the U.S.A? Evangelical Christianity? Who's brand? And whichever one you pick the Catholics and Mormons and Goat knows how many other sects will scream. America hasn't yet seen a good religious war, wouldn't it be amusing if the fight against Radical Islam resulted in a new 30 Years War among Christian sects?

Next - 119. Catching up