Food dislikes
Here's the kind of thing the internet is so handy for. In "real" life I've ran into any number of people with odd (to me) food preferences -- a dislike of mushrooms is common, also of cilantro and green bell pepper -- but someone in my online group brought up foods people can't stand and the list amazes me.
We had stumbled on avocado and raisins before, many people in the group detest both. Now we're adding olives, ham, ketchup & mustard. And today we've added cherries -- at first Maraschino and then all cherries -- and marzipan!!
Gustatory synesthesia! (Everybody downs a drink.) I shouldn't be surprised at any of this since my mother never tasted any of the items on this list -- though that puts her dietary preferences in an entirely different (not taste-based) category. But some of the items on this list I consider to be among life's greatest small pleasures: avocado, cilantro, real cherries, marzipan. And if you told me I would have to live the rest of my life without raisins or mustard I would not be happy.
My point is that these taste based differences are as striking to me as the more conventional forms of synesthesia. They are at least more comprehensible than the emotional synesthesia I wrote about last time -- someone pushing away a bowl of guacamole is puzzling but it also means there's more for me. Someone doing a good job but not being able to acknowledge that, or feel any pride in the accomplishment, is much harder for me to get my mind around.
An excellent example of this for me was that recent Women's March in Oakland I greened. As a "good dog" (in a previous life) I thrive on pleasing whoever is in charge. For that event there was no one else around for most of the day so I had to please myself, and I can be something of a perfectionist. I can nit pick any number of aspects of my work that day (and have done so) but I can also see that I did more than could reasonably have been expected of me, and I can feel pride in my work (while still keeping in mind a short list of things I would have done differently and will try to do differently if I'm ever in that situation again.) To not be able to correctly assesses my performance would be as scary as Oliver Sacks' list of freakish neurological conditions like being unable to recognize faces, or read words, or speak, or imagine color.
Sense and Sensibility
I'm watching the most recent mini-series version of this again. So delightful. This time, as I watch, I've been thinking of "parade." In the first of the three parts there was one instance of parade in the usual sense -- a funeral parade in this case -- but I lost track of the instances of parade in the other sense. (And yes, I have in mind Parade's End here.) We see the Dashwoods on parade first at the head of their establishment at Norland Park and then in their reduced circumstances at the cottage and at the home of their cousin, where we also see that landed family in welcoming parade. Every social visit requires a degree of parade.
This would be hard to defend, but I rather think this degree of parade is related to the way people, within living memory, would dress up to go to town -- or go downtown. Gloves and hats. Dressing for church may be the last of this sort of parade. My (Boomer) generation was probably the death of all this, and I was never a fan of it in any case, but now one has to wonder if this was also part of the path that lead to Donald Trump.
Jane Austen's works are spiced with memorable minor characters (Sophie Thompson has nailed two of these parts), but one that I never thought of in this way was Anne Steele, until Daisy Haggard took her in hand. There should be special prizes for running away with a part like that.
I've finished my re-watch, and I would also like to praise Dan Stevens. I don't think anyone could play Edward Ferrars better than this. That penultimate scene where he has to play through the awkwardness of the Dashwoods thinking he -- rather than his brother Robert -- had recently married Lucy Steele was brilliant.
I would even praise Mark Gatiss. John Dashwood is one of the most thankless parts, as he is so weak and it would be so easy to turn him into a joke. Fanny knows very well what she is about, but John, I think, truly thinks himself to be a an honorable man. Mark gives us a character who is shallow and conventional, but decent in his own way. He truly believes the advice he gives Elinor.
And I'm sure I've written about this elsewhere, but I do prefer this Maryanne to the one Austen wrote. For one thing she actually grows as a character over the course of the novel, as a young woman of 17 ought to do, and as the written Maryanne (to my recollection) fails to do. Elizabeth in P&P, and Emma, and Catherine in Northanger all develop as characters. Even Anne Elliot grows a bit of a backbone. But Elinor seems to be perfect from the start. We will not speak of Fanny Price.
Curious
Felt a bit better today -- fever down -- and thought I could go out and get a sandwich to bring home without sounding too consumptive. (Success.) But as I was dressing to go out I thought to myself, "Last time I was this sick I ended up buying a condo." And that's when the penny dropped.
It is almost exactly 20 years from when I was sick that time -- to within a week or two. I felt worse then (didn't leave my apartment for about a week) but had no obvious symptoms like now -- cue wet cough. I still don't know what was wrong with me in 1997, but the condo had been my salvation. And then I pushed it back even farther...
The last time I had a chest cold like this must have been within a year or so of 1977, so 40 years ago. Maybe I should leave a note to myself to prepare for 2037. Though I'm not sure how.
When life gives you phlegm...
A friend revealed an unexpected childhood -- and resulting personality disorder -- which got me thinking about how that "nuclear family" idea works better than I had expected. My family was an "ideal" nuclear family -- a hydrogen atom. Technically speaking we were Deuterium: I would say Mother was the proton and Dad was the neutron, since present fathers are more optional than mothers.
Even in the post-quantum, post-Linus Pauling world, the model of Deuterium is pretty simple, though you do have to recall that uncertainty is always a factor. But the "shell" in which the electron (me) can be found couldn't be easier to determine.
But when you start adding other siblings the picture starts to grow complex, as is the case with heavier atoms. (We're going to have to drop the family aspect of the nucleus here, unfortunately, as I was thinking about Tritium if step-parents were involved, but that doesn't really work out electrodynamically. Sad, really.)
With Pauling, electron "shells" get very odd.
The shell of each additional electron/sibling is shaped by the increased distance from the protons/parents and by interference with the other siblings. And so someone can end up with Impostor Syndrome simply from the social factors controlling the family unit.
I know that one of the reasons I adore Jane Austen is the rich family life in many of her novels. As an only child, siblings are endlessly fascinating to me. Like having a pony. And then, over time, you collect so many stories of dysfunctional sibling relationships that you need Elizabeth and Jane to hold on to. Now I see people with affectionate relationships with siblings as the true wonders of life.
But I'm not through with Impostor Syndrome since, as everyone knows, why settle for one metaphor when you can squeeze in two. Here's the above-the-contents description from Wiki,
Impostor syndrome (also known as impostor phenomenon or fraud syndrome) is a concept describing high-achieving individuals who are marked by an inability to internalize their accomplishments and a persistent fear of being exposed as a "fraud". The term was coined in 1978 by clinical psychologists Pauline R. Clance and Suzanne A. Imes.[1] Despite external evidence of their competence, those exhibiting the syndrome remain convinced that they are frauds and do not deserve the success they have achieved. Proof of success is dismissed as luck, timing, or as a result of deceiving others into thinking they are more intelligent and competent than they believe themselves to be. Some studies suggest that impostor syndrome is particularly common among high-achieving women.[2]
Synesthesia (Goat, I hope no one turns this into a drinking game) deals with how some of us (at least) perceive the world differently through our senses, but is this difference in perception any less real than seeing sound or tasting words? If your familial context -- or just life in general -- has shaped you in such a way that you are unable to perceive, and enjoy, your own success, then that is a most profound distortion of the world.
And I couldn't help noting that Impostor Syndrome seems to be the opposite of Donald Trump's condition. So how many variations are there on this theme. How many people puzzle us because they suffer from a kind of emotional synesthesia that we can't comprehend, unless they tell us or someone writes a book about them?
Anyway. Something to ponder as my sinuses drain and my temperature returns to below normal.
No, I'm not done yet. The problem with the QED atomic view above is that it's still too simple to describe the complexity of family relationships. I have to suggest we go... to the QCD side. Let's say a family starts when two quarks get together. (Meaning of chroma and spin TBD.) Often the quarks, not confident in the Strong Force (new definition), conceive a gluon to increase their bond -- sometimes this works, sometimes it doesn't. In the later case you have a gluon shaped by both a Strong and Weak (remote or dead or unknown parent) force.
The evolving gluon can also be shaped by siblings and step-quarks. The presence of younger siblings, for instance, tends to turn the oldest into a semi-quark. Qualities and weaknesses of the quarks (again, represented by chroma and spin) effect different gluons differently based on gender (spin?) and birth order and other factors.
Sometimes the gluon grows to be a healthy quark, escapes the Strong force without rejecting the Weak force of extended family. Other times the gluon escapes too quickly, before it is fully matured, or else can never escape the Strong force at all.
I wish I could assign this to someone to flesh out. That must be the fun part of being a teacher.
Painting
"A sane person might inquire why I waited until the coldest week of the year to paint the back of our building," I thought to myself as I shivered up on my aluminum extension ladder while filling knots in the plywood sheet that serves as our basement door. There are reasons, I tell myself. For one thing I thought our painting would have been done weeks ago. I had no idea it would prove so hard to schedule painters. And I had no idea we would be having such a wet season. Until a few days ago, it hadn't even occurred to me to worry about the unprotected wood back there -- and when I went back to check on it, I found they had used a good quality, though knotty, plywood that seems to be holding up well.
But it was also clear to me that I could handle this myself. Once I start thinking how I can do something I'm pretty much doomed to do it.
Musicophilia
I've come to the section on my old friend synesthesia. Here's a great passage that highlights a bit of what fascinates me about this condition:
p180 Synesthesia seems to go with an unusual degree of crossactivation between what, in most of us, are functionally independent areas of the sensory cortex... There is some evidence that such "hyperconnectivity" is indeed present in primates and other mammals during fetal development and early infancy, but is reduced or "pruned" within a few weeks or months after birth... behavioral observations of infants suggest "that the newborn's senses are not well differentiated, but are instead intermingled in a synesthetic confusion."
Perhaps, as Baron-Cohen and Harrison write, "we might all be colored-hearing synthetes until we lose connections between these two areas somewhere about three months of age." In normal development... a synthetic "confusion" gives way in a few months, with cortical maturation, to a clearer distinction and segregation of the senses, and this in turn makes possible the proper cross-matching of perceptions which is needed for the full recognition of an external world and its contents -- the sort of cross-matching which ensures that the look, the feel, the taste, and the crunch of a Granny Smith apple all go together. In those individuals with synesthesia, it is supposed, a genetic abnormality prevents complete deletion of this early hyperconnectivity, so that a larger or smaller remnant of this persists in adult life.
And then there's this:
...The rapidity with which synesthesia can follow blindness would scarcely allow the formation of new anatomical connections in the brain and suggests instead a release phenomenon, the removal of an inhibition normally imposed by a fully functioning visual system...
p182 Within weeks of losing his sight, Jacques Lusseyran developed a synesthesia so intense as to replace the actual perception of music...
I had no sooner made a sound on the A string, D or G or C, than I no longer heard it. I looked at it. Tones, chords, melodies, rhythms, each was immediately transformed into pictures, curves, lines, shapes, landscapes, and most of all colors. . . . At concerts, for me, the orchestra was like a painter. It flooded me with all the colors of the rainbow. If the violin came in by itself, I was suddenly filled with gold and fire, and with red so bright that I could not remember having seen it on any object. When it was the oboe's turn, a clear green ran all through me, so cool that I seemed to feel the breath of night. . . . I saw music too much to be able to speak its language.
Oddly, this reminds me of the account of blind people who were confused and overwhelmed -- and not really pleased -- when they were able to finally see after a surgical procedure. And, of course, that was in Annie Dillard's Pilgrim at Tinker Creek, before she talked about "the tree with the lights in it," which I've been thinking about this whole chapter. Whatever the thing-in-itself is in fact, we are unsettled when the way we perceive it changes.
Now we are at Tourette's. It turns out there is a "phantasmagoric" form of Tourette's where people respond uncontrollably to music. There are two different ways of viewing this and both interest me. First there's the notion that we are in some way an instrument played by music. Just as a movie score can move us against our will to feel a certain way, for some people a piece of music can force them to move and mimic and in other ways respond.
Then there's the other way:
p231 Tourette's brings out in stark form questions of will and determination: who orders what, who pushes whom around. To what extent are people with Tourette's controlled by a sovereign "I," a complex, self-aware, intentional self, or by impulses and feelings at lower levels in the brain-mind? Similar questions are brought up by musical hallucinations, and brainworms, and varied forms of quasi-automatic echoing and imitation. Normally we are not aware of what goes on in our brains, of the innumerable agencies and forces inside us that lie outside or below the level of conscious experience -- and perhaps this is just as well. Life becomes more complicated, sometimes unbearably so, for people with eruptive tics or obsessions or hallucinations, forced into daily, incessant contact with rebellious and autonomous mechanisms in their own brains....
Many of the dysfunctions Sacks has written about here are in fact failures of consciousness or "self," as we've learned about those terms in the previous blog. It is so tempting to view these cases as software app failures due to scrambled code or damaged media or maybe a failed chip.